ON THIS DATE (18TH NOVEMBER) 153 YEARS AGO : 'HOME RULE' ISSUE INTENSIFIES.
'ISAAC BUTT (1813-1879) POLITICIAN, BARRISTER AND PHILOSOPHER (pictured).
Isaac Butt was born in Glenfin, Donegal, on the 6th September 1813.
His father, the Reverend Robert Butt, became Rector of St. Mary's Church of Ireland, Stranorlar in 1814 so Isaac spent his childhood years in Stranorlar. His mother's maiden name was Berkeley Cox and she claimed descendency from the O'Donnells. When Isaac was aged twelve he went as a boarder to the Royal School Raphoe and at the age of fifteen entered Trinity College Dublin.
He trained as a barrister and became a member of both the Irish Bar and the English Bar. He was a conservative lawyer but after the famine ('1169' comment - it was an attempted genocide) in the 1840s became increasingly liberal. In 1852 he became Tory MP at Westminster representing Youghal, Co. Cork and in 1869 he founded the Tenant League to renew the demand for tenant rights. He was a noted orator who spoke fervently for justice, tolerance, compassion and freedom. He always defended the poor and the oppressed.
He started the Home Rule Movement in 1870 and in 1871 was elected MP for Limerick, running on a Home Rule ticket. He founded a political party called The Home Rule Party in 1873.
By the mid 1870s Butt's health was failing and he was losing control of his party to a section of its members who wished to adopt a much more aggressive approach than he was willing to accept. In 1879 he suffered a stroke from which he failed to recover and died on the 5th May in Clonskeagh, Dublin.
He was replaced by William Shaw who was succeeded by Charles Stewart Parnell in 1880. Isaac Butt became known as "The Father of Home Rule in Ireland". At his express wish he is buried in a corner of Stranorlar Church of Ireland cemetery, beneath a tree where he used to sit and dream as a boy.' (from here.)
On the 18th November, 1873 - 153 years ago on this date - a three-day conference was convened in Dublin to discuss the issue of 'home rule' for Ireland. The conference had been organised, in the main, by Isaac Butt's then 3-year-old 'Home Government Association', and was attended by various individuals and small localised groups who shared an interest in that subject.
Isaac Butt was a well-known Dublin barrister who was apparently viewed with some suspicion by 'his own type' - Protestants - as he was a pillar of the Tory society in Ireland before recognising the ills of that creed and converting, politically, to the 'other side of the house' - Irish nationalism, a 'half way house', if even that - then and now - between British imperialism and Irish republicanism ie Isaac Butt and those like him made it clear that they were simply agitating for an improved position for Ireland within the 'British empire', as opposed to Irish republicans who were demanding then, and now, a British military and political withdrawal from Ireland.
Over that three-day period the gathering agreed to establish a new organisation, to be known as 'The Home Rule League',and the minutes from the conference make for interesting reading as they highlight/expose the request for the political 'half way house', mentioned above - 'At twelve o'clock, on the motion of George Bryan, M.R, seconded by Hon. Charles Ffrench, M.P., the Chair was taken by William Shaw, M.R.
On the motion of the Rev. P. Lavelle, seconded by Laurence Waldron, D.L., the following gentlemen were appointed Honorary Secretaries : — John O.Blunden, Philip Callan M.P, W.J.O'Neill Daunt, ER King Harman and Alfred Webb. ER King Harman read the requisition convening the Conference, as follows : —
We, the undersigned feel bound to declare our conviction that it is necessary to the peace and prosperity of Ireland, and would be conducive to the strength and stability of the United Kingdom, that the right of domestic legislation on all Irish affairs should be restored to our country and that it is desirable that Irishmen should unite to obtain that restoration upon the following principles : To obtain for our country the right and privilege of managing our own affairs, by a Parliament assembled in Ireland, composed of her Majesty the Sovereign, and the Lords and Commons of Ireland.
To secure for that Parliament, under a Federal arrangement, the right of legislating for, and regulating all matters relating to the internal affairs of Ireland, and control over Irish resources and revenues, subject to the obligation of contributing our just proportion of the Imperial expenditure. To leave to an Imperial Parliament the power of dealing with all questions affecting the Imperial Crown and Government, legislation regarding the Colonies and other dependencies of the Crown, the relations of the United Empire with Foreign States, and all matters appertaining to the defence and the stability of the Empire at large...' (from here.)
The militant 'Irish Republican Brotherhood' (IRB) was watching those developments with interest and it was decided that Patrick Egan and three other members of the IRB Supreme Council - John O'Connor Power, Joseph Biggar and John Barry - would join the 'Home Rule League' with the intention of 'steering' that group in the direction of the IRB.
Other members of the IRB were encouraged to join the 'League' as well, and a time-scale was set in which to completely infiltrate the 'League' - three years.
However, that decision to infiltrate Isaac Butt's organisation was to backfire on the Irish Republican Brotherhood : the 'three-year' period of infiltration ended in 1876 and in August 1877 the IRB Supreme Council held a meeting at which a resolution condemning the over-involvement in politics (ie political motions etc rather than military action) of IRB members was discussed ; after heated arguments, the resolution was agreed and passed by the IRB Council, but not everyone accepted that decision and Patrick Egan, John O'Connor Power, Joseph Biggar and John Barry refused to accept the decision and all four men resigned from the IRB.
Charles Stewart Parnell was elected as leader of the 'Home Rule League' in 1880 and it became a more organised body - two years later, Parnell renamed it the 'Irish Parliamentary Party' and the rest, as they say, is history...
On the 18th November, 1919, it became known that a number of bank officials had left the Munster and Leinster Bank and the National Bank in the Millstreet area in the county of Cork at about 8am on the previous day, in a car and a horse-drawn carriage, to attend a cattle fair at Knocknagree in that county.
The bank officials were carrying a total of £16,700 between them, a huge amount of money in those days, which would be worth at least €1.3million Euro today.
Both vehicles were held-up by at least five armed men and the money was taken.
On the 24th April, 1920, Liam Lynch, Officer Commanding of the Cork No 2 Brigade IRA, accompanied by between 100 and 200 Volunteers, representing the Irish Republican Police (IRP), arrived in Cork to investigate the robbery and, a short time later, the Republican Police arrested eight men, seven of whom confessed to having been involved in the robbery.
About £10,000 was recovered and the seven arrested men were sentenced to various lengths of deportation from, or exile within, Ireland.
We could do with a (proper) Police Force like that now ; there are tens of thousands of people here that will have to be deported.
Anyway - as it took about five months to discover who the thiefs were and where they had hidden the stash (no Revolut/PayPal in those days ; the bank notes and bags of coins were buried in cabbage patches, vegetable fields, thatched roofs, haystacks and under floorboards in their own houses!) it was not surprising that the leader of the gang, a Mr Daniel Buckley, and the rest of his crew had 'lived it up', spending between them an estimated £7,000.
Plus, as an extra bonus, the IRP had been seen to exercise its authority.
==========================
On the same date that the bankers were spreading the cash around (! -17th), a British Army soldier, a Mr George Smith (18, 'Service Number 9948') from Great Yarmouth in England was, according to a report in a newspaper on the 18th, spending a few hours in the town of Larne, in the county of Antrim, in Ireland.
The newspaper reported that he "accidentally drowned".
He was attached to 'A Coy', 1st Battalion of the 'Unit/Ship' Norfolk Regiment, and is buried in Victoria Cemetery on Victoria Road in Carrickfergus, in the county of Antrim, in Ireland.
==========================
FAILING THE CHILDREN...
In every county in Ireland, children must put up with woefully inadequate school buildings.
The government says it is doing its best to improve the situation, but parents and teachers complain that the State's attitude is bureaucratic, secretive and uncaring.
Niall Stanage investigates.
From 'Magill Magazine', March 2002.
Aisling Moroney, a teacher at Ardkeeran National School, said -
"The children are very cramped.
It is almost impossible to do anything which doesn't involve them sitting at their desks, it's very hard to do arts and crafts because there is no hot running water and no sink in the room.
They are basically confined to being taught in quite a traditional way through sheer lack of space."
The school building is at the end of its natural life and everyone, including the Department of Education's inspectors, seems to agree that a new school has been needed for years.
In 1999, the local parish priest offered Ardkeeran National School a green field site just a few hundred yards away from its current location ; the Church said it would donate the land free of charge...
(MORE LATER.)
On Thursday evening, 18th November 1920, uniformed members of the British Army and their comrades in the RIC broke into Coláiste Uladh (the Irish College) in Cloghaneely(/Cloughaneely), in the county of Donegal, and also gained entry to the adjacent co-operative stores/shop (which also served as the venue for a Dáil Court).
Both premises were looted, the windows smashed out and the remaining contents were trashed, before the perpetrators left the scene.
Early in the morning of the 19th, they returned, entered and set fire to both buildings.
As expected, no one was ever charged or prosecuted for the destruction of the buildings.
==========================
On the same date that their troops and their 'police force' in Ireland were looting colleges and stores/shops in Ireland, the British 'Chief Secretary for Ireland', a Mr 'Sir' Hamar Greenwood (who was only eight months in that position) announced/confirmed in the British 'House of Commons' (!) that a Mr 'Sir' Basil Clarke ('Mr Verisimilitude'!), the 'Director of Public Information' in the Westminster Ministry of Health, had been seconded to Dublin Castle in Ireland to take control of the newly structured propaganda office known as the 'Public Information Department/Department of Publicity'.
Mr Clarke was a 'spin doctor' who operated under the correct assumption that whoever supplied the news/story could control the narrative around that 'information'.
Mr Greenwood described Mr Clarke as "..a Press Officer of long experience whose duty it is to communicate to the Press officially authenticated information with regard to events of public interest in Ireland..."
The Irish republican publication, 'The Irish Bulletin', frequently exposed Mr Clarke as the spoofer he was, but one issue he couldn't mislead people on was his health : he fell ill to a stroke and died in his own country, England, at 68 years of age, in 1947.
No truth in the rumour that his last words were "told ya it was only a head cold..".
==========================
"We, the undersigned, while condemning murder and outrage by whomsoever committed, deplore the disastrous state of affairs in Ireland at this time.
We believe that force breeds force and reprisals suggest reprisals, but that the fires of brotherly love and goodwill, by God's spirit, lead to amity and peace.
We ask, therefore, that military terrorism may cease and a truce be arranged on both sides, so that, in an atmosphere of peace, negotiations for a settlement may be carried on..."
- a statement published in 'The Times of London' newspaper on the 18th November, 1920, and signed by sixteen (Protestant) bishops in Ireland.
On the 8th July, 1921, 'Truce Talks' began in the Mansion House in Dublin and, literally within days, those preliminary discussions led to formal talks during which (on the 5th December 1921) the British Prime Minister, a Mr David Lloyd George, told the Irish delegates to 'take it or leave it' (ie "immediate and terrible war" if they didn't take it!) and, the next day (6th), the 'Treaty [of Surrender]' was signed.
But it didn't lead to "an atmosphere of peace", it still hasn't, nor will it...
==========================
ON THIS DATE (18TH NOVEMBER) 106 YEARS AGO : 'HANSARD' TRANSCRIPT OF DEBATE ON CAPTURE OF FOUR ENGLISH OFFICERS IN CORK BY REBELS.
(Or - 'Rebel motor cars? - BAN THEM!')
This discussion in the British 'House of Commons' on the 18th November, 1920, was commented on in the newspapers of the day on the 19th November -
HANSARD 1803–2005 - 1920s - 1920 - November 1920 - 18 November 1920 - Commons Sitting - IRELAND.
OFFICERS CAPTURED.
HC Deb 18 November 1920 vol 134 cc2072-4
Mr. PENNEFATHER (by Private Notice) asked the Secretary of State for War whether he had any information to impart relating to the four officers taken by force out of a train at Waterfall, County Cork, the day before yesterday, and carried off in rebel motor cars, and whether, in view of this further proof of the assistance to crime afforded by privately-owned motor cars, the Government would at once prohibit their use in the disturbed areas?
Mr. DEVLIN : "What is a "rebel motor car"?
The SECRETARY of STATE for WAR (Mr. Churchill): "The only information which I have at present is that two Education Officers, Captain M. H. W. Green, Lincolnshire Regiment, and Captain S. Chambers, Liverpool Regiment, and an officer of the Royal Engineers, Lieut. W. Spalding Watts, were captured by the rebels.
I understand that Captain Green and Lieutenant Watts might have been witnesses of a murder of a police sergeant and that Captain Chambers was the principal witness against Father O'Donnell, who was arrested in October, 1919, for seditious speeches.
Presumably, these are the reasons why they were kidnapped, but I do not know the circumstances of their capture. With regard to the last part of the hon. Member's question, I think ample powers already exist under the Restoration of Order in Ireland Regulations.
Certain restrictions regarding the use of motor vehicles are already in force, and I understand that further drastic restrictions will come into operation on 1st December."
Mr. TERRELL : "Have these officers been released?"
Mr. CHURCHILL : "No."
Mr. DEVLIN : "The right hon. Gentleman brings in the trial, and the statement that Father O'Donnell was arrested for seditious language. For what reason ho dons (sic - 'he done'?) that, I do not know. Will he state that the court-martial acquitted him of that charge?"
Mr. CHURCHILL : "I did not attach importance to that. I have given the answer specially framed for me in answer to this question."
Mr. DEVLIN : "Who framed it for you?"
Mr. CHURCHILL "I had no communication whatever with the hon. Member (Mr. Pennefather), and there is no ulterior design behind the framing of the answer." (From here.)
We also found the following information in relation to this incident :
Capt M H W Green - removed and shot. Capt S Chambers - removed and shot. Lt W S Watts - removed and shot...there were 4 officers in mufti in a 3rd class compartment travelling from Cork (they thought it less conspicuous to travel 3rd class). There were 10 people in the compartment. The officers were en route to Bere Island. The soldiers were Lt R R Goode (inspector of Army Schools), Capt Reedy R.E., Chambers and Green.
The train stopped at Waterfall, 6 miles from Cork.
Three armed civilians entered their compartment. Looking at Chambers one of these armed men said "That is one of them" and looking at Green said "That is the other".
Chambers and Green were then marched out with their hands up and were last seen at the bridge over the railway....In 'The Year of Disappearances' (link here) the author makes a case for mistaken identity, for the Green the IRA wanted being George Edward Green, and not MHW Green...Watts had decided to travel First Class and was by himself.
Reedy only realised Watts was missing when the train got to Kinsale Junction and he could not find Watts...Goode added to his statement that he knew that Chambers had been responsible for the arrest of Father O'Donnell (Chaplin to the Australian Forces) in Oct 1919 for seditious language....Goode also said that Chambers and Green had the previous week been witnesses to the murder of 2 RIC constables at Ballybrack in the course of a railway journey.
Goode believed that Green was carrying an automatic pistol, but believed that the others were unarmed...1921 Nov 29- The IRA confirm that the men were executed, but details of their burial place did not emerge... (from here) and these British Army documents also make for interesting reading.
The lesson, whether it should have been learned in 1920 (if not centuries earlier!) or will be learned even at this late stage by those who think they have secured their political future and that of this Free State, is a simple one : 'Ireland unfree shall never be at peace'.
ON THIS DATE (18TH NOVEMBER) 106 YEARS AGO : BRITISH REPRISAL KILLINGS IN CORK.
On the 17th November 1920, a 46-year-old Kerry-born RIC Sergeant, James O'Donoghue, who had 22 years 'service' in that particular 'police force' and was about to be promoted to Head Constable, was shot dead in White Street in Cork city by three IRA men (Charlie O'Brien, Willie Joe O'Brien and Justin O'Connor) , who were standing in a gateway, waiting for a target that never showed.
The IRA unit were about to leave the area when they were spotted by O'Donoghue, who had just left his home at Tower Street, in full uniform, to make his way to the RIC barracks at Tuckey Street, about a half-mile of a walk from his house.
According to reports of the incident, the RIC man "came upon" the IRA men and he was shot dead as a result.
The next day - the 18th November (1920), 106 years ago on this date - a gang of masked men, believed to be RIC and/or Black and Tans from the Tuckey Street barracks, forced their way in to the O'Brien house, looking for Charlie and Willie Joe ; they shot Charlie, leaving him for dead, and then shot his brother-in-law, Eugene O'Connell, who died at the scene.
The British execution gang then broke into the near-by home of Patrick Hanley and shot him dead, and then turned their guns on his friend, Stephen Coleman, severely wounding him, and a James Coleman was also attacked by the gang and shot dead.
An IRA investigation into how the IRA unit had been exposed led the organisation to believe that informers had been at work and three men were shot dead as a result - John Sherlock, 'Din-Din' O'Riordan and Eddie Hawkins (whose father, Dan, was seriously wounded in that action).
Incidentally, a week after the IRA killed the RIC man, the Cork Command IRA officially apologised in writing to his family and let it be known that they were 'furious' that their Volunteers had taken it on themselves to carry-out that operation ; Mr O'Donoghue was popular in the area and apparently was decent enough to individual republicans whenever their paths crossed.
But it was the uniform and what it represented that was the target, not the person wearing it.
ON THIS DATE (18TH NOVEMBER) 106 YEARS AGO : IRA GO SHOPPING FOR AIRPLANE PARTS...
On the 18th November 1920 - 106 years ago on this date - an aeroplane made an emergency landing in a field near Punches Quarry in Cratloe, County Clare, and word quickly spread in the area that the craft was fitted-out with a machine gun.
The British 'authorities' heard about the incident, as did the local IRA unit, and the former ordered their man in the Limerick area, 2nd Lieutenant MHS Last, to organise a platoon from 'C' Company, 'Oxon and Bucks' (the 'Oxfordshire and Buckinghamshire Light Infantry' regiment) and get to the site to guard the wreck, which they did and, in an act of bravado (given the times that were in it!) the British forces apparently posted no sentries and built and lit a large turf fire to make themselves comfortable. And visible!
The IRA, too, had arrived on site ; Volunteers attached to the 2nd Battalion of the East Clare Brigade, with Brigade Training Officer Volunteer Joseph Clancy and Volunteer IRA Officer Ned O'Brien in command, accompanied by about one dozen other fighters (including Volunteers Jack McNamara, Bill Lynch and two of the O'Halloran brothers), armed with weapons from their arms dump at Ballymorris House in the village of Cratloe, took up firing positions at the edge of the quarry.
And a gun battle ensued -
'1920 Nov 18. A platoon from "C" Company, 1st Battalion of the Ox and Bucks were guarding the crashed RAF plane near Punches Quarry, Cratloe area.
They were under the command of 2nd Lieutenant M.H.S. Last.
A group of I.R.A. volunters led by Joe Clancy (Brigade Training Officer East Clare Brigade) had seen the plane come down and got togather an attacking group from IRA men lying low at (Annie 'Nan') Hogans house in Cratloe.
Their objective was to capture the aeroplane's machine gun.
After dusk Clancy and his group climbed to the top of Punches Quarry and opened fire at 17.30 on the unsuspecting Ox and Bucks troops who were grouped round a large bonfire that they had lit to keep themselves warm. The IRA said that there were no sentries posted...'- more here.
The British soldiers returned heavy machine-gun fire, forcing the IRA party to withdraw toward a wood at the rear of the quarry without capturing the weapon.
(Incidentally, a British Army Private, a Mr Alfred William Spackman ['Service Number 5373641'] was shot dead during the engagement and one of his comrades, a Mr Maurice Robins ['Service Number 5373574'] was severely wounded and died from his injuries in the military hospital in Fermoy, County Cork, on the 2nd March 1921.
All Volunteers returned safely to base.)
ATTITUDES.
"We have chosen as a society to forfeit the notion of accountability deliberately and on our own behalf."
By Declan Lawn.
From 'Magill Magazine', August 2002.
In January 1985, 'Magill Magazine' celebrated its 100th issue and, in a long editorial, Vincent Browne looked back over the previous eight years of the magazine's life and assessed the ways in which Irish society had changed for better or for worse.
Mostly, he concluded, it was for worse.
Issues of civil liberties had more or less stultified during the period, with the Gardai continuing to act in a highly questionable manner, seemingly immune to censure or criticism.
The Northern conflict, apparently intractable, raged on and was in fact about to enter a particularly bleak era, little or no progress had been made on the issue of women's rights, with women still predominantly in the lower paid jobs, still largely absent from the judiciary and from politics, and still discriminated against by prohibitions on contraception and divorce...
(MORE LATER.)
"The RIC stationed in the six counties will not be handed over at present but will be placed as from November 22nd at the disposal of the Northern Government (sic - Stormont Assembly)...".
- an internal circular sent on the 18th November 1921 by British Army Major-General 'Sir' Henry Hugh Tudor to his 'Deputy Inspector General', the 'Divisional Commissioner' in Belfast and the 'Commandant of the Auxiliary Division'.
On the 22nd, Westminster 'officially' transferred all executive responsibility re the RIC and the 'Specials' for 'security, law and order, and the administration of justice' (!) to the newly formed Stormont Assembly, but no mention was made about the so-called 'Auxiliaries'.
Perhaps Westminster was holding back what it considered to be its 'trump card', maybe just in case the RIC and 'Specials' needed manners put on them later...?!
Anyway - Major-General 'Sir' Henry Hugh Tudor was a British Army officer who served as the 'Police Adviser' and de facto 'Chief of Police' in Ireland from May 1920 until those bandits were disbanded in 1922 (he had actually styled himself 'Chief of Police', a title unique in Irish history!) and he also held sway over the 'Dublin Metropolitan Police' (DMP) and all British Intelligence operations in Ireland were approved (or not) first by him.
This man - 'Churchill's Enforcer in Ireland' - (Mr Churchill and Mr Tudor were actually the best of friends) knew he was a wanted man by the IRA and Mr Churchill knew it, too - so, in 1922, Mr Tudor was taken out of Ireland and placed in 'Mandatory Palestine' as the General Officer Commanding the Forces and Inspector-General of Police' in that British-acquired (!) terrority, but he didn't leave Ireland on his own - he took a massive contingent of former Black and Tans and Auxiliaries with him to form the new British 'Gendarmerie' there ; the exporting and importing of a diseased body.
Mr Tudor "retired from military service" in 1924 and, having no doubt introduced 'security, law and order, and the administration of justice' in that area, too (!), but unwilling to return to England as he was made aware that the IRA still wanted to have a word with him, moved lock, stock and barrel to Canada!
Newfoundland ; 120 Military Road in Saint John's, by all accounts.
That's where Mr Tudor settled, calling himself 'Hughie' (!) and working, believe it or not, as a codfish buyer/fishmonger for Ryan and Company in Bonavista, and later for George M. Barr's fishing industry in Saint John's, in Newfoundland.
By all accounts, poor 'Hughie' lived in absolute terror of the IRA finding him : he armed himself with a massive .455 calibre Wilkinson Webley revolver in one pocket, a smaller, nearly invisible backup gun in another pocket and a set of brass knuckles in another pocket whenever walking around the streets of his 'safe haven'.
He spent his 40 years in Newfoundland living an incredibly reclusive life - his conscience might have been at him, hopefully.
Major-General 'Sir' Henry Hugh Tudor died from natural causes at 94 years of age on the 25th September 1965 at the Veterans Pavilion of the Saint John's General Hospital in Saint John's, Newfoundland, in Canada.
He is buried in the Anglican Cemetery on Forest Road in Saint John's, having escaped justice.
(Incidentally, t'is said that in the late 1940's/early 1950's, the IRA sent two Volunteers to Newfoundland to have that word with Mr Tudor, but a local priest intervened and the Volunteers left him alone.)
==========================
"In the course of 1919 Lord French, Mr Macpherson, Sir John Taylor, Mr E. Saunderson and Mr Watt had convinced themselves that the only cure for the sporadic and infrequent exhibitions of force in Ireland was the total excommunication of Sinn Fein.
The fact that Sinn Fein was a political creed escaped the notice of these gentlemen.
They merely regarded it as a convertible term with the physical force faction.
They decided that the Irish problem would be settled if the majority of the people in Ireland were forbidden to think, discuss, talk, write or speak the political views which they favoured.
In high places in Ireland there were some – not many – of whom Sir Joseph Byrne (Inspector General of the RIC at the time and one of the few Catholics in 'high places') was one, who realised the full implications of 'proclaiming', that is, proscribing, in its entirety, a political creed.
No attention was paid to their warnings that such a procedure would reinforce indefinitely the physical force party, and would justify their methods as the only instrument left to them..."
- A memo from a Mr Warren Fisher (pictured), the 'Permanent Secretary to the British Treasury', which he sent to his political bosses Messrs Austen Chamberlain and Llyod George on the 18th November 1921.
Fine words, to be sure but, on occasion over the 850+ years that the English have interfered in Ireland, we have heard such fine words before.
The words we need to hear are "Sorry. Goodbye..."
==========================
DEATH IN THE MEDITERRANEAN...
Desmond Boomer, a Belfast engineer working in the Libyan oil-fields, disappeared seven years ago.
Officially, the plane on which he was a passenger crashed as a result of mechanical failure and pilot error.
But is that the real story?
Or were the Irishman and his fellow passengers unwitting victims of the shady war between Islamic fundamentalism and Mossad, Israel's intelligence network?
A special 'Magill' investigation by Don Mullan, author of 'Eyewitness Bloody Sunday'.
From 'Magill' magazine, January 2003.
On the 3rd December 2002, Mandy Boomer officially became a widow, exactly seven years and one day after she last spoke to her 38-year-old husband on a long-distance telephone call.
On the 6th August 2002, she had written a poem entitled 'Questions Unanswered' -
Years have gone by, with still no word,
If anything is known, none of us have heard.
We're only people of no consequence,
Those who may know stay quiet ;
They sit on the fence.
That Mandy Boomer, now 43, should consider herself and children to be abandoned as "people of no consequence" is a sad indictment of a nation whose passport her husband carried...
(MORE LATER.)
At dawn on Friday, 17th November 1922, four young Dublin Brigade IRA Volunteers (pictured) — Peter Cassidy, James Fisher, John Gaffney, and Richard Twohig — were shot by firing squad in Kilmainham Jail in Dublin by the Staters.
All four were convicted solely of 'unauthorised possession of revolvers'; convicted, that is, by those 'authorised' to do so by their political and military 'Head Office' in London.
The next day (Saturday 18th November 1922) 'The Irish Independent' newspaper (a pro-partition, pro-Stater media outlet, then and now) published a prominent editorial opposing the Leinster House newly enacted policy of executing IRA POW's, stating that executing young men on minor charges of weapon possession would backfire, alienate public sympathy and deepen the cycle of bitterness rather than end the conflict (other critics and commentators at the time suspected the four young Dublin Volunteers were executed to create 'a legal and political precedent').
On that same Saturday (the 18th) four Dublin Brigade IRA Volunteers died in a premature landmine explosion on the Naas Road in Dublin while preparing an ambush intended as direct retaliation for the Kilmainham executions.
Volunteers Captain Thomas Maguire, Patrick J. Egan, Bernard Curtis and Thomas Phelan were about to lay a landmine at the Bluebell/Inchicore end of the Naas Road (beside the Lansdowne Valley area) to hit a Free State troop convoy returning to their Baldonnel base from guard duty in Kilmainham Jail, but the weapon detonated prematurely.
RIP Volunteers Thomas Maguire, Patrick J. Egan, Bernard Curtis and Thomas Phelan.
And again, on the 18th, a rally in support of republican prisoners, organised by the 'Republican Prisoners Defence Committee', was being held in O'Connell Street in Dublin when shots were fired into the attendees from a machine-gun mounted on a passing FSA armoured car.
M/s Charlotte Despard, who had been addressing the meeting, later stated that the Free State Army had opened fire without provocation.
Seven people were seriously wounded in the attack, including M/s Lily(/Lillie) Bennett, a member of Cumann na mBan, who was shot in the back and died a short time later.
No arrests or criminal charges were ever brought against the Free State soldier(s) responsible for the murder of M/s Lily Bennett - Leinster House treated the incident as 'a military security matter' rather than a civilian crime.
RIP M/s Lily Bennett.
==========================
In the 1920's, the Staters held regular town hall dances in which they blended moral-improving State military and political pageantry, jazz music, fundraising for injured colleagues and - most important to them - the normalising of their presence in a given area.
One of these propaganda pieces was due to be held in the dancehall in Killaloe, a village in the county of Clare, on Saturday night, the 18th November 1922, and the IRA were aware of it.
An IRA ASU established an ambush/sniper position on high ground across the River Shannon on the County Tipperary side...and waited.
In order to impress the girls, Stater troops would wear their full uniform on the way to the dance, during the proceedings, and afterwards, on their way home (...usually to their own gaff, having failed 'to pull a bird'!).
On the night of the dance, about forty Stater soldiers were present and, despite 'keep-your-distance'-notifications to the public from the IRA, so were about the same number of local civilians.
Whether he was specifically targeted or not, an IRA Volunteer fired a number of long-distance shots into the dancehall and one of the attendees fell to the floor, badly wounded.
The injured man was an FSA Sergeant, a Mr Thomas Manifold (29,'Service Number 56587'), a Dublin man, from the Raheny/Balgriffin area.
Before he showed loyalty to the half-crown in 'H Company, 4th Battalion, 1st Dublin Brigade', Mr Manifold was employed as a farm labourer, and was the sole fatality of that IRA operation.
His military command listed him as having been 'Killed in Action' and stated that he did not die at the scene - he lost that battle either later on that night or in the early hours of the 19th.
In most reports, local chronologies and accounts of that shooting, he is referenced, in writing, as 'Sergeant Manaphone' ; a phonological slip of the tongue, nothing sinister, in our opinion.
==========================
'A search party of troops visited Headford last week in a round-up operation.
About to search a house when a man was noticed running from the building.
He was called on to halt and a Mauser Rifle, four bombs and a quantity of ammunition was found in his possession.
He gave his name as O'Brien and is believed to be from Tuam.
On the way back to Galway the troops were ambushed on two occasions but failed to find the attackers and reached Galway without mishap...'
- that happened on the 18th November, 1922, as quoted from 'Civil War In Galway', by Nollaig Ó Gadhra (pictured).
We located details on three different O'Brien's that it could have been - provided that indeed was actually his real surname, which is doubtful - but, because we're not positive, we'll say no more...!
==========================
Thank you for visiting, and for making the time to read our few scribbles - appreciated, and tell yer pals about us!
We'll be back on Wednesday, 2nd December 2026 and, between this and then, ya can catch me mouthin' off on 'X' and 'Facebook' as well, if yer missing me that much!
Sharon and the team.
Slán go fóill anois!
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
1873 - "HER MAJESTY THE SOVEREIGN AND THE LORDS AND COMMONS OF IRELAND..."
Labels:
Alfred William Spackman.,
Bill Lynch,
Dan Hawkins,
Din-Din O'Riordan,
Eddie Hawkins,
Eugene O'Connell,
Jack McNamara,
James Coleman,
John Sherlock,
Joseph Clancy,
MHS Last,
Ned O'Brien,
Patrick Hanley,
Stephen Coleman




















